SkillsAdd

lvtd-llc/skills

beta-reader-feedback

Plan beta reading rounds for practical nonfiction and turn reader comments, abandonment, confusion, skepticism, and negative feedback into manuscript revisions.

First seen Jun 21, 2026

Installation

$ npx skills add lvtd-llc/skills --skill beta-reader-feedback
View on skills.sh ↗ GitHub repository ↗

Summary

  • Plan beta reading rounds for practical nonfiction and turn reader comments, abandonment, confusion, skepticism, and negative feedback into manuscript revisions.
  • Use when recruiting beta readers, preparing reader instructions, synthesizing feedback, deciding whether a book is ready, or improving a draft from real reader data.

Similar popular skills

Related neighbors and high-traction skills in the same topics — useful to compare before installing.

frontend-design Same topic
anthropics/skills

Guidance for distinctive, intentional visual design when building new UI or reshaping an existi…

866.4K installs
agent-browser Same topic
vercel-labs/agent-browser

Browser automation CLI for AI agents. Use when the user needs to interact with websites, includ…

810.4K installs
vercel-react-best-practices Same topic
vercel-labs/agent-skills 697.8K installs
web-design-guidelines Same topic
vercel-labs/agent-skills

Review UI code for Web Interface Guidelines compliance. Use when asked to "review my UI", "chec…

617.3K installs
microsoft-foundry Same topic
microsoft/azure-skills

Build, deploy, evaluate, optimize, fine-tune, and manage Microsoft Foundry agents, models, and …

576.5K installs
azure-diagnostics Same topic
microsoft/azure-skills

Debug Azure production issues on Azure using AppLens, Azure Monitor, resource health, and safe …

568.9K installs

Also in this package

Other skills from lvtd-llc/skills · top by installs.

npx skills add lvtd-llc/skills
game-balance-economy 119 django-htmx 78 game-mechanics-design 74 calibredb 71 alpinejs-django 68 game-playtest-planning 67 game-story-world-character 67 book-toc-lab 66 b2b-sales-constraint-diagnosis 63 make-product-viral 63

Browse all from lvtd-llc/skills

More details

Agent compatibility

Declared targets from SKILL.md / docs. Unmarked agents are not listed — the skill may still install via the CLI.

Claude Code Declared
Cursor Not declared
Codex Declared
GitHub Copilot Not declared
Windsurf Not declared
Gemini CLI Not declared
Cline Not declared
OpenCode Not declared

Repository health

Stars 1
License LICENSE
Default branch main
Open issues 0
Status Active

Skill metadata

Parsed from SKILL.md frontmatter.

Version0.1.0
LicenseMIT
CompatibilityCodex, Claude Code, and other Agent Skills-compatible clients.
Declared agents claude-code codex
More metadata
version
0.1.0
displayName
Beta Reader Feedback
category
Writing
tags
writing,books,nonfiction,beta-readers,feedback

Package contents

Files included with this skill beyond the listing page.

  • skill md SKILL.md 3,669 B
  • docs SUMMARY.md 354 B

History

  1. First seen on skills.sh
  2. First recorded snapshot · 62 installs

SKILL.md

Beta Reader Feedback

Core Lens

Beta reading is product testing for a useful nonfiction manuscript. The goal is not praise, proofreading, or opinion collection. The goal is to discover whether readers want the promise, receive the value, stay engaged, and know what to do next.

Use this skill to:

  • Plan beta reader rounds.
  • Recruit the right readers.
  • Write reader instructions.
  • Classify and synthesize comments.
  • Detect hidden boredom from abandonment.
  • Decide what to revise next.
  • Decide when the manuscript is ready for polishing.

Reference Routing

Need Read
Core beta-reading model and terminology references/core/knowledge.md
Operating rules and decision criteria references/core/rules.md
Example instructions, feedback classes, and synthesis patterns references/core/examples.md
Quick checklist for setup and review references/core/checklist.md
Run a beta iteration workflows/run-beta-iteration.md
Synthesize comments into revision decisions workflows/synthesize-feedback.md

Workflow

1. Confirm Beta-Readiness

Start beta reading after the draft is coherent enough for motivated readers, but before it has been polished so heavily that major changes feel costly.

If the draft is still a vague TOC, use book-toc-lab. If it needs structural pacing work first, use reader-experience-edit.

2. Choose The Reader Batch

For each iteration, define:

  • Target reader profile.
  • Desired number of deeply engaged readers.
  • Invitation list, usually larger than the desired reader count.
  • Any influential readers to save for a later, stronger draft.

3. Prepare The Feedback Surface

Use a tool that supports live comments and engagement visibility.

  • Prefer cloud-hosted commenting.
  • Do not email PDFs around as the main workflow.
  • Tell readers what feedback matters now.
  • Ask for confusion, skepticism, missing information, boredom, value, and applicability.

4. Classify Feedback

Group feedback by signal:

  • Evidence of value.
  • Confusion or missing information.
  • Skepticism or weak proof.
  • Factual issues, overgeneralization, or oversimplification.
  • Unnecessary drama or distracting sentences.
  • Boredom, abandonment, or comment drop-off.
  • Application problems after reading.

5. Revise By Signal Strength

Prioritize changes that unblock more readers.

  • Treat abandonment as data.
  • Treat negative feedback as a lens, not a command.
  • Do not argue with readers in the document.
  • Follow up when the book is supposed to change behavior after reading.

Output Format

When helping with beta feedback, return:

  1. Beta-readiness or setup diagnosis.
  2. Reader recruitment and instruction plan.
  3. Feedback taxonomy or synthesis table.
  4. Ordered revision priorities.
  5. Finish criteria: what evidence would make the manuscript ready for polish.

Quality Bar

Separate reader signals from author defensiveness. Do not merely summarize comments. Convert them into revision decisions, open questions, and next beta-round tests.